Meta’s Facebook app has been hit with a fine in Italy after regulators found the platform accessed users’ phone photos and videos without clear permission. The Italian data protection authority, Garante, imposed an €805 million penalty and ordered the company to overhaul the feature within two months.
Background of the violation
The issue centers on Facebook’s “gallery suggestion” feature, launched in 2023 for Android devices. The tool scans a user’s photo library and proposes images or videos for posting while the user browses the app. According to the regulator, the feature was enabled by default and relied on a single permission that covered multiple functions. Users were shown a generic prompt reading “enable other functions,” which did not explain that granting the permission also allowed the app to read their entire gallery.
How the regulator assessed consent
Garante identified three specific shortcomings in Meta’s consent process:
- One permission for many features – Facebook used a single gallery permission for several unrelated functions, rather than requesting a distinct consent for the suggestion tool.
- Vague messaging – The on‑screen notice failed to clarify that the permission would let the app suggest photos from the device.
- Default activation – The feature was turned on automatically, without requiring users to opt‑in.
The authority warned that full permission could let the app continuously read a phone’s whole photo archive, a level of access that cannot be audited by users or regulators.
Legal basis for the fine
The regulator concluded that Meta breached Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which transposes the EU ePrivacy Directive into national law. The rule mandates that any access to information stored on a personal device must be based on freely given and informed consent, regardless of whether the data is transmitted elsewhere or any harm occurs.
Meta argued that Ireland’s data protection regulator should handle the case, citing its European headquarters. Garante rejected the claim, asserting jurisdiction over the violation affecting Italian users.
Penalties and compliance timeline
The €805 million fine reflects the seriousness of the breach. In addition to the monetary penalty, Garante issued a set of compliance orders:
- Within 60 days: Stop the feature by default for all users, including those who previously granted permission, and present a separate, explicit consent request that explains the purpose and how to disable it.
- Within 30 days: Submit an initial report on steps taken to meet the order.
- Within 90 days: Provide a full update on the measures implemented.
Meta has announced its intention to appeal, describing the sanction as “disproportionate” in a statement reported by Reuters.
Sources
This report is based on information from:
